Weekly reviews of crab cakes around the MD and DC area

September 19, 2012
Published in Crab Cake Reviews
font size decrease font size increase font size
Print
Email

Sly Horse Tavern

The Sly Horse Tavern has been around since 1985, located on Crofton's Village Green. The restaurant may look like a historic house from the 18th century, but it is really a replica of Colonial Williamsburg's Raleigh Tavern. They bill themselves as "modern American" cuisine, even if the menu has a bit of a German influence. Just don't ask about the name -- it's a secret they aren't willing to share. But one secret the CCR is willing to share is their crab cakes. How were they? Read on!

The Chesapeake Crab Cake entree is served with potato, vegetable, and rolls (although our potato was substituted with rice). Also available are fried Chesapeake Crab Balls on the appetizer menu. Entree only comes broiled, and is market price. Served with lemon wedge and what appears to be a spicy aioli (maybe spiced with Old Bay?).

The crab cake is comprised of jumbo lump crab meat held together with what appears to be bread and mayonnaise. Crab is in lumps amongst some broken pieces. Binder is smooth and creamy with a bready texture. Not much by way of spicing.

Crab has a really good flavor to it, but the binder ends up being a bit one note. While there is a bready texture to the cake, it doesn't really have much flavor. You can only really taste the crab, and while it is tasty, there should be a little more flavor complexity that doesn't come in the form of a side sauce. The centers of our cakes were a bit mushy, so there could have been a little less binder and possibly also have been cooked a bit longer.

Additional Info

Restaurant Name: Sly Horse Tavern
Address: 1678 Village Green Crofton, MD 21114
Neighborhood: Crofton
Restaurant Type: Local
Website: http://www.slyhorsetavern.com/
Review Date: 09/13/2012 8:00pm
Atmosphere: Not Busy
Item(s) Ordered: Chesapeake Crab Cakes
Cooking Style: Broiled
Other Styles Available: No
Available by mail order?: No
Price: 29.00
Order Type: Double Platter
Crab Content: Jumbo Lump
Filler: Average
Spice: None
Overall Impression: Average
Rating (out of 5 crabs):

Rate this item

1
2
3
4
5

(0 votes)

Tagged under

More in this category: « Pelican Cove Jack's Bistro »

Restaurant Name

Name of the restaurant at the time of the review. Using proper, advertised name and not any nicknames. Stadium names will be used, as the stands there are permanent (at least for the current season). Festival/Event stands will use the business name.

Address

Physical address of the restaurant. In the case of a chain, the establishment visited will be used.

Neighborhood

Name of the neighborhood/area that the restaurant is located in. More useful for big cities like Baltimore. Smaller locations will have just the town/city name used.

Restaurant Type

Local = Single establishment/location
Local Chain = Multiple establishments in the same town
Regional Chain = Multiple establishments in the same geographical area
National Chain = Multiple establishments across the country
Stand/Kiosk = Stadium, festival or event that does not have a physical address/permanent location. Stadium names will be used, as the stand will be assumed to be permanent, at least for the current season. Stands at festivals/events will use the business name.

Review Date

Date and time the review took place. Time often refers to when I sat down at a table, not specifically when I took my first bite of crab cake.

Atmosphere

Approximation of how busy the restaurant was at the time of the review. May have an effect on the quality that goes into the crab cake and overall experience. If food is made to order but the kitchen is slammed, then food may be rushed out the door. Conversely, if going to a stand on a slow day, food may be pre-cooked and then warmed up upon ordering.

Item(s) Ordered

Menu name of the item ordered. There may be multiple versions on the same menu, or the same item may be named differently if the menu changes on a regular basis.

Cooking Style

How the crab cake was cooked. Not always obvious, at which case a best approximation is made. Typically either fried or broiled are the most popular cooking styles, others may be available and will be indicated as such.

Other Styles Available

Indicates multiple versions of crab cakes are offered on the menu. Does not list which other styles are available, as that list can get to be a bit unmanageable. Fret not, my loyal readers! The CCR will make an effort at some point in the future to return and review it. For science!

Price

The price paid at the time of review. May not reflect the price if you visit the same establishment, especially if the crab cakes are "market price" or on a daily special. Every effort will be made to indicate the regular price in the body of the main review.

Order Type

Single Platter = single crab cake + at least one side
Double Platter = two crab cakes + at least one side
Combo Platter = two crab cakes of differing styles + at least one side
Sandwich = single crab cake on a bun
Appetizer = ordered off of the appetizer menu
Single = single crab cake and nothing else
Store Bought = bought at a store, but may also refer to carryout from a restaurant that also does mail order
Other = anything else that does not fit the above, expanded upon in the body of the main review

Crab Content

Description of crab contained within the crab cake. This definition is a bit subjective both to what the reviewer considers the crab content to be, and what the restaurant does. Even if jumbo lump is being used, for example, it is possible for those jumbo lumps to be broken up into smaller lumps and/or shreds. Origin vs end product can be different, but in the end its all crab. However, if a jumbo lump crab cake comes out with nothing but shreds, then the CCR does not view this as a jumbo lump crab cake.

Therefore, the CCR will use the following definitions in its reviews to assess the end product, despite the restaurants claims (which will be noted in the main body of the review):

Jumbo Lump = large lumps of crab meat present, often the size of a sugar cube
Lump = large lumps of crab meat that often have a finger-like shape to them
Mix = mixture of lump and shredded meat
Shredded = no lumps of crab meat, all shredded meat

Filler

Assessment of the amount of filler used, not the actual ingredients used. Minimal shows signs of bread crumbs and the like being used, whereas Too Much indicates that the cake has hardly any crab at all.

Spice

Assessment of the amount of spices used, not the actual ingredients used. Minimal indicates the slight presence of spices (such as Old Bay) or flavors other than the crab meat (may come from the mustard and/or mayo being used), whereas Too Much indicates that the flavor of the crab is undetectable.

Overall Impression

A personal assessment of the crab cake after some thought and reflection. The CCR tries to be fair and objective in all of its reviews, but that does not mean that the reviewer won't have some sort of opinion as to how good the crab cake is compared to all of the others out there. Please note that this is subjective, and use the pictures, main review and user comments to determine if the crab cake in question is worth trying for yourself or not. (And post your experience in the comment section as well!)

End FAQ